Green Shoots Optimism: The Biggest ‘Bait and Switch’ in History
Source: http://feedproxy.google.com/~r/ContrarianProfits/~3/EUM77J1y8Ek/18442Posted on Monday, June 29th, 2009 | In Market Commentary
All this week, we’ve been sounding the alarm of the so-called economic “green shoots.” These have now been exposed as being pure propaganda designed to lure investors back into stocks and to allow banks to recapitalize through share issuances at artificially elevated prices.
Bond investors are no doubt breathing a sigh of relief. Now that investors are waking up to the fact that a recovery is not “around the corner” after all, the yield on 10-year T-Notes is dropping and bond prices are rising again.
As long as investors have an appetite for low-yielding Treasurys (10-year Notes were yielding 3.53% yesterday), the government will have a tough time pushing its “green shoots” fairytale.
We challenge even the best paid of President Obama’s economic spin doctors to find the silver lining in the following two recent data points. This from MoneyMorning.com:
- Unemployment claims unexpectedly rose yesterday, as the number of US workers filing new claims jumped by 15,000 in the week ended June 20 to a seasonally adjusted 627,000, the Labor Department reported. The four-week moving average of initial claims, a less volatile measure, rose to 617,250 from 616,750, signaling the US job market is stagnant.
- US gross domestic product (GDP) contracted at a 5.5% annual rate in the first quarter after plunging at a 6.3% pace in the fourth quarter of 2008, the Commerce Department said yesterday (Thursday). That means the US economy just went through its worst eight-month period in more than 60 years, according to MarketWatch. The government last month estimated GDP fell at a 5.7% pace in the quarter ended March 31.
If you in any doubt about the dangers of relying on the mainstream media for your economic and financial information, here’s how the BBC, Britain’s state-sponsored news agency, had this to say about the worst eight-month contraction of the US economy in more than 60 years.
US economy better than expected
The US economy shrank at an annualised rate of 5.5% in the first three months of 2009, better than previously thought, government figures show.
This is pitiful. And it’s clear evidence that governments and mainstream media outlets really do believe that people are too stupid to notice what’s going on in the economy. Don’t be suckered. This kind of nonsense is dangerous: listen to it and you could get wiped out as an investor.
If you want to know why the economy is in the ditch… and ain’t “bouncing back” anytime soon, look no further than this chart. It shows the total level of equity in household real estate from 1952 to 2009. (Hat tip, The Big Picture.)
Last 5 posts by Contrarian Profits
- Gold – Not the end, but possibly a correction - November 24th, 2009
- How do retail sales stack up in an atypical recovery? - November 24th, 2009
- The Best Energy Investments in the World - November 23rd, 2009
- Transportation Sector: powered by recovery - November 23rd, 2009
- The Dollar, the Euro, and being Bullish on Gold - November 20th, 2009
BBC, Britain, contrarian profits, household real estate;, mainstream media, mainstream media outlets;, Market Commentary, obama, president, state-sponsored news agency, United States




ContrarianProfits.com is a financial news and opinion website with a twist. As investment guru Rick Rule puts it, “You are either a contrarian or a victim.” In the financial world, most people are losers because they just don’t know what game they’re playing. They think they can just get “into the market” along with everyone else, do what everyone else does, and they will make money. Not likely. By the time you’ve paid commissions, spreads, fees, taxes – and suffered the consequences of inflation – you’ll be very lucky just to have as much money as you started with.
ContrarianProfits.com is a contrarian site, in the sense that we provide ideas, opinions and recommendations that often run counter to the mainstream financial press. We do this not just to be contrary, but because we’ve realized that Rick is right. You don’t make money by following the crowd; you make money by leading it.
Why is this so? Well, it’s obvious that if you do the same thing everyone else does you’ll get the same results everyone else gets. On average, and over the long run, real investment returns for the typical investor cannot exceed the rate of growth of the economy itself. Everybody can’t get richer faster than everybody else. Real economic growth in the US today averages about 3% per year; if you don’t make any mistakes, that’s about what you can expect. Few people may be satisfied with 3% per year, but most feel comfortable in the middle of the financial herd and are happy to take whatever that gets them. If you’re one of those people, you will probably not like our site. It will make you uncomfortable.
If, on the other hand, you’re willing to look at things a little differently, you’ll appreciate the views of many of our columnists, contributors and visionaries.