Why Emerging Markets Are So Volatile
Posted on Sunday, June 22nd, 2008 | In Foreign MarketsWe are sometimes asked why emerging markets are so much more volatile than developed markets. The answer is that, due to their relative size, money flows between them cause most of the volatility effect.
Consider a real world situation that most of us have seen — a stream emptying in to a pond and another stream at the the other end of the pond draining the overflow.
Think of the streams as the emerging markets and the pond as the developed markets. Think of the water as money.
The water in the stream feeding the pond moves quickly. When the water enters the pond, it slows as it spreads out in the breadth and depth of the pond. When the water enters the stream draining the pond overflow, it moves quickly again.
The streams are narrow and shallow by comparison to the pond, which is broad and deep. Any fixed amount of water moving through the streams must move more quickly than the same amount of water moving through the pond between the two streams.
Today, the developed markets free-float (represented collectively by VTI, EWC and EFA) is about nine times the size of the emerging markets free-float (represented by VWO). Within the total equity allocation of all investors, an increase or decrease in the developed markets allocation will show up as a magnified opposite change in the emerging markets allocation.
If investors decreased their current 89% developed markets allocation to an 88% allocation (a minimal change), the emerging markets would change from 11% to 12% (a substantial change). The inverse changes are similarly minimal for developed markets and substantial for emerging markets.
The comparatively minimal nature of the developed markets changes create only minimal supply-demand pressure between money and shares, whereas the comparatively substantial nature of the corresponding emerging market changes create substantial supply-demand pressure between money and shares.
The greater the supply-demand pressure, the greater the degree of price change.
Considering the current 9:1 developed-to-emerging markets ratio, if the current bear market causes collective investors to become more risk averse and to significantly reduce their emerging markets exposure in favor of developed markets, the emerging markets would be crushed.
Richard Shaw
QVM Group LLC
Last 5 posts by Richard Shaw
- Stocks vs Bonds Long-Term and Short-Term - January 8th, 2009
- Equity Asset Allocation Didn’t Work in 2008. - January 7th, 2009
- Screen for Top Yielding Stocks by Sector - January 4th, 2009
- One Chart 2008 Synopsis - December 31st, 2008
- Convertibles Are An Interesting Speculation - December 31st, 2008
Emerging Market, Emerging Markets, equity allocation, EWC, Foreign Markets, market changes, minimal supply, substantial nature, VWO, world situation
 About Richard Shaw (http://www.QVMgroup.com)
Richard is a principal of QVM Group LLC, a fee-based investment advisor based in Connecticut with clients across the country. He provides investment coaching to "do-it-yourself" investors, and manages portfolios for those who prefer not to make their own decisions. His investment approach is based on value, asset allocation, benchmarking, expense control, risk management, customizing portfolios to each client's specific circumstances, and regular communication about strategy and performance. The QVM Group team also provides municipal refinance services, strategic business planning and financial analysis service for new ventures, private acquisition analysis, and custom investment research. Richard's extensive experience, includes serving on the Board of Directors of Aberdeen Asset Management PLC (London Stock Exchange: ADN), membership on the Board of Directors of Phoenix Investment Counsel (renamed Virtus Investment Advisors), a U.S. pension manager and investment advisor to the Phoenix Funds (renamed Virtus Funds), as well as serving as Managing Director of a series of offshore investment funds based in Luxembourg. He has led institutional asset management sales and had overall responsibility for management of a U.S. mutual funds broker-dealer. He was a charter investor and member of the Board of Directors of several internet companies, including Lending Tree prior to its IPO. He is a graduate of Dartmouth College. QVM Group LLC is a Registered Investment Advisor. Visit the QVM Group website http://www.qvmgroup.com/QVMinvest/ |
No recommendations, either expressed or implied, are being made to buy, sell, hold or short any of the mentioned stocks. No legal, tax or accounting advice is expressed or implied. Always contact your attorney, CPA, or tax advisor before acting on any legal or tax issues. StraightStocks.com is not responsible for the content, products, or services of any of the advertisers on this site. StraightStocks.com receives compensation from advertisers on this blog. Services and products referred to herein are trademarks, registered trademarks, servicemarks, and/or registered servicemarks of their respective trademark or servicemark owners.